Notes on
selected chapters in: Henderson, E and
Nathenson, M (eds) (1984) Independent
Learning in Higher Education.
Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Educational
Technology Publications Inc.
Dave Harris
Introduction
The intention is to develop a 'theory', [in the
main sense used in educational technology --
a strange mixture of description and managerial
proscription]. A lot of psychological
material is reviewed about motivation and
cognitive organization, including the usual
suspects—Maslow, Kohlberg, Piaget and Dewey, and
even Pask and Scott on information
processing. Morgan's approach based on the
Gothenburg School appears. This is the Ed
Tech Man's catechism of all time greats. It
is relentlessly optimistic, in seeing study
systems in terms of humanistic psychology, for
example.
There is only really one critical section based on
Becker and Miller and Parlett [on student
instrumentalism and cue consciousness
respectively], and even here, this is seen as an
unfortunate tendency for extrinsic motivation to
be dominant.
Brown, D. 'Case Study 10: Case Studies on
Television', 211--220
Television case studies use the conventions and
language of television, including documentary and
realist convention, and those that name to produce
programmes that are 'concrete and synthetic'
[confirmation of these techniques in educational
broadcasting is drawn from Bates and
Gallagher*. As examples, interviews are
edited to juxtapose views, the documentary format
appears in programmes on life in a monastery or
conditions in different industries which affect
women's work. Different kinds of
conventional narrator appear. The intention
is to be open-ended and to encourage an active
response. Even Bates and Gallagher found
little effect on students, however, leading to
their proposals to clarify intentions at the
expense of content, to list concepts, to offer
more guidance ( see Bates
here) . Student perceptions seem to
vary: some see television programmes as a source
of information rather than as a resource to
develop their course skills (213).
One solution is clearly to offer more broadcast
notes, even 'media booklets', or to make
supplementary TV programmes to show students how
to interpret TV. These might take the form
of follow-up cassette material to be studied
immediately after a television programme, and
could include, say, the comments of the
participants. Case studies could be
redesigned more radically, to encourage tune
interrogation of the material, for example by
freezing the action while students were asked
questions, or including action replays.
However, there are dangers here including the 'sad
irony [that]… students are pushed even more
firmly into accepting the programme makers view of
reality'(215).
An alternative is clearly to expose the basic
construction of television programmes, including
the way they are encoded and decoded [and explicit
reference to Hall]
(216). [Not a great deal is made of Hall,
though, only the point that academic TV must offer
a selective perception of events which cannot be
assumed to correspond with that of
students]. It is clear that educational TV
can clash with 'good TV' [with a reference to Gallagher]: good TV
assumes shared knowledge. There is some
dispute about whether the open university
programmes are judged in the same way as ordinary
TV, but it is unlikely that academic perspectives
are shared.
Reference is made to the piece by Thompson
[confirmed by Gallagher again, although she blames
students' lack of skills]. Brown is not so
keen to blame students, more to see it as a matter
of the power of conventions. He ends by
agreeing with Thompson that TV tends to show only
one construction of events. They might be
helped to distance themselves if they experienced
frequent 'interruptions'.
* Bates, A. and Gallagher, M. (1977)
'Improving the effectiveness of OU TV case studies
and documentaries', a paper produced by the Audio
- Visual Research Group in the OU Institute of
Educational Technology.
More education studies
|
|